In defense of Apache’s post on Tumblr…
Let’s look at it objectively - for all the hooplah and negative response rising up around this one post, there are only two negative comments made in comparison to positive. Frankly, those who take offense to a simple word-of-warning are simply mistaken to bristle so easily. The author of that post is a respected member of online and offline Swing Dance communities and speaks from a place of experience. There’s nothing accusatory or disparaging in the tone of the writing with which to take umbrage
As for a touch of the Ivory Tower perspective coming down, this is all old territory. Many of us who have a foothold in Tumblr put our two-cents-worth in a few months ago when Jerry Almonte made the first mention of our prescence to the outside blog-o-sphere. Some consensus came from those of us on the inside, that being:
- Yes, Tumblr is a community with schema of it’s own that outsiders may find puzzling and/or are unwilling to take the time to familiarize themselves with.
- Yes, perhaps not all the content generated here is on-par with independent bloggers in the broader swing dance community.
- But, despite it all, those of us on Tumblr have managed to find our own corner of the internet for expression, regardless of our unrelated daily lives.
So fellow Tumblrs, just smile and nod when outsiders fail to comprehend this platform. Let’s not devolve into superior-inferior small-minded comparisons. The beauty of Tumblr comes in it’s variability and ease of use. So what if we may not win the ear of event organizers around the world?! A little camaraderie from other non-influential dancers is still a lovely thing.
Ambition to develop a following was not part of my reasons for opening a Tumblr account. Likewise, I did not get into Swing Dance in order to scale the ranks and climb into the Pro circuit. Those things would be lovely indeed, and even possible, if I pursued them to the exclusion of everything else. Which, for the sake of my sanity, is not going to happen.
Cataloging appealing songs, pictures, videos, etc. for future purposes was part of my thinking; I like pretty dresses, awesome swivels and kick-ass performances. And I see no shame in that what-so-ever.